Highlights
-
Only by competing to be unique can an organization achieve sustained, superior performance.
-
Competitive advantage lies in the activities, in choosing to perform activities differently or to perform different activities from rivals.
-
Trade-offs are the economic linchpins of strategy for two reasons. First, they are an important source of differences in prices and costs among rivals. Second, they make it difficult for rivals to copy what you do without compromising their own strategies.
-
Good strategies depend on the connection among many things, on making interdependent choices.
-
Paradoxically, continuity of strategy improves an organization’s ability to adapt and to innovate.
-
The key to competitive success—for businesses and nonprofits alike—lies in an organization’s ability to create unique value. Porter’s prescription: aim to be unique, not best. Creating value, not beating rivals, is at the heart of competition.
-
Strategy explains how an organization, faced with competition, will achieve superior performance.
-
Competing to be the best leads inevitably to a destructive, zero-sum competition that no one can win. As offerings converge, gain for one becomes loss for the other. This is the very essence of “zero sum.” I win only if you lose.
-
This, says Porter, is competitive convergence. Over time, rivals begin to look alike as one difference after another erodes.
-
Instead of competing to be the best, companies can—and should—compete to be unique.
-
Competing to be the best feeds on imitation. Competing to be unique thrives on innovation.
-
The real point of competition is not to beat your rivals. It’s not about winning a sale. The point is to earn profits.
-
These five forces—the intensity of rivalry among existing competitors, the bargaining power of buyers (the industry’s customers), the bargaining power of suppliers, the threat of substitutes, and the threat of new entrants—determine the industry’s structure, an important concept that may sound academic but is not (figure 2-1).
-
Here’s the general rule: the more powerful the force, the more pressure it will put on prices or costs or both, and therefore the less attractive the industry will be to its incumbents.
-
Note that if an industry doesn’t create much value for its customers, prices will barely cover costs. If the industry creates a lot of value, then structure becomes critical in understanding who gets to capture it. Industries can, and often do, create a lot of value for their customers or suppliers while the companies themselves earn very little for their efforts.
-
Both industrial customers and consumers tend to be more price sensitive when what they’re buying is Undifferentiated Expensive relative to their other costs or income Inconsequential to their own performance
-
What percentage of an industry’s purchases/sales does a supplier/buyer represent? Look at the data and map out how it is trending. How painful would it be to lose that supplier or that customer?
-
Switching costs work in the buyer’s favor when the buyer can easily drop one vendor for another.
-
When buyers see little differentiation in the industry’s products, they have the power to pit one vendor against another. As
-
They can credibly threaten to vertically integrate into producing the industry’s product itself. Producers of beer and soft drinks have used this tactic to keep a lid on the prices of beverage containers.
-
Switching costs play a significant role in substitution. Substitutes gain ground when buyers face low switching costs,
-
Entry barriers protect an industry from newcomers who would add new capacity.
-
When rivalry among the current competitors is more intense, profitability will be lower. Incumbents will compete away the value they create by passing it on to buyers in lower prices or dissipating it in higher costs of competing.
-
Rivals have high fixed costs and low marginal costs, creating the pressure to drop prices because any new customer will “contribute to covering overhead.”
-
Capacity must be added in large increments, disrupting the industry’s supply–demand balance and leading to price cutting to fill capacity.
-
The product is perishable, an attribute that applies not only to fruit and fashion but also to a wide range of products and services that quickly become obsolete or lose their value. A hotel room, an airline seat, or a restaurant table that goes unfilled is “perishable.”
-
there are a limited number of structural forces at work in every industry that systematically impact profitability in a predictable direction.
-
Managers often mistakenly assume that a high-growth industry will be an attractive one. But growth is no guarantee that the industry will be profitable. For example, growth might put suppliers in the driver’s seat, or, combined with low entry barriers, growth might attract new rivals. Growth alone says nothing about the power of customers or the availability of substitutes. The untested assumption that a fast-growing industry is a “good” industry, Porter warns, often leads to bad strategy decisions.
-
Porter offers this rule of thumb: where there are differences in more than one force, or where differences in any one force are large, you are likely dealing with distinct industries.
-
How can you position yourself in relation to the five forces? Can you find a position where the forces are weakest? Can you exploit industry change? Can you reshape structure in your favor?
-
“Strategy,” Porter writes, “can be viewed as building defenses against the competitive forces or finding a position in the industry where the forces are weakest.”
-
The real point of competition is earning profits, not taking business away from your rivals. Business competition is about the struggle for profits, the tug-of-war over who gets to capture the value an industry creates.
-
Companies compete for profits with their direct rivals, but also with their customers, their suppliers, potential new entrants, and substitutes.
-
The collective strength of the five forces determines the average profitability of the industry through their impact on prices, costs, and the investment required to compete. A good strategy produces a P&L better than this industry average baseline.
-
Industry structure is dynamic, not static. Five forces analysis can help anticipate and exploit structural change.
-
If you have a real competitive advantage, it means that compared with rivals, you operate at a lower cost, command a premium price, or both. These are the only ways that one company can outperform another. If strategy is to have any real meaning at all, Porter argues, it must link directly to your company’s financial performance. Anything short of that is just talk.
-
The financial measure that best captures this idea is return on invested capital (ROIC).
-
For Porter, then, differentiation refers to the ability to charge a higher relative price.
-
strategy choices aim to shift relative price or relative cost in a company’s favor. Ultimately, of course, it’s the spread between the two that matters: any strategy must result in a favorable relationship between relative price and relative cost. A distinct strategy will produce its own unique structure.
-
The sequence of activities your company performs to design, produce, sell, deliver, and support its products is called the value chain. In turn, your value chain is part of a larger value system.
-
If your value chain looks like everyone else’s, then you are engaged in competition to be the best.
-
As the Southwest example shows, ferreting out cost drivers can be like detective work. It demands both creativity and rigorous analysis.
-
Matching the value chain—the activities performed inside the company—to the customer’s definition of value was a new way of thinking just twenty-five years ago. Today it has become conventional wisdom.
-
The value chain focuses managers on the specific activities that generate cost and create value for buyers.
-
Porter uses the phrase operational effectiveness (OE) to refer to a company’s ability to perform similar activities better than rivals.
-
But simply improving operational effectiveness does not provide a robust competitive advantage because rarely are “best practice” advantages sustainable. Once a company establishes a new best practice, its rivals tend to copy it quickly. This treadmill of imitation is sometimes called hypercompetition.
-
No company can afford sloppy execution. Inefficiency can overwhelm even the most distinctive and potentially valuable strategies. But betting that you can achieve competitive advantage—a sustainable difference in price or cost—by performing the same activities as your rivals is a bet you will probably lose.
-
Competitive advantage is not about beating rivals; it’s about creating superior value and about driving a wider wedge than rivals between buyer value and cost.
-
Competitive advantage means you will be able to sustain higher relative prices or lower relative costs, or both, than your rivals in an industry. If you have a competitive advantage, it will show up on your P&L.
-
competitive advantage means you have created value for customers and you are able to capture value for yourself because the positioning you have chosen in your industry effectively shelters you from the profit-eroding impact of the five forces.
-
Your value chain must be specifically tailored to deliver your value proposition. A value proposition that can be effectively delivered without a tailored value chain will not produce a sustainable competitive advantage.
-
If all rivals produce the same way, distribute the same way, service the same way, and so on, they are, in Porter’s terms, competing to be the best, and not competing on strategy.
-
The first test of a strategy is whether your value proposition is different from your rivals. If you are trying to serve the same customers and meet the same needs and sell at the same relative price, then by Porter’s definition, you don’t have a strategy.
-
Focus refers to the breadth or narrowness of the customers and needs a company serves. Differentiation allows a company to command a premium price. Cost leadership allows it to compete by offering a low relative price. These broad characterizations of strategy types capture the fundamental dimensions of strategic choice relevant in any industry.
-
limits make it possible to develop a value chain that is different from that of rivals who have chosen to offer a different kind of value.
-
Choices in the value proposition that limit what a company will do are essential to strategy because they create the opportunity to tailor activities in a way that best delivers that kind of value.
-
If the same value chain can deliver different value propositions equally well, then those value propositions have no strategic relevance. Only a value proposition that requires a tailored value chain to deliver it can serve as the basis for a robust strategy.
-
No cookbook or expert system can reliably churn out winning strategies. By definition, strategy is about creating something unique, making a set of choices that nobody else has made.